Supporters of the Magpies are increasingly seeing Eddie Howe's outfit as a fickle ally. On their day, they transform into the very entertainers, delivering high-intensity displays. Yet, on other occasions, once-dependable figures like their midfield linchpin and his teammates simply go missing.
Compounding these problems is a late-game game management riddled with a pronounced streak of chaos. Before their trip to Old Trafford, the facts tell a concerning picture: they have squandered 13 crucial top-flight points from leading positions this campaign and are yet to keep a shutout in 10 straight games across all competitions. Claiming a win at Old Trafford would be only their second-ever domestic triumph on the travel this season.
Conversely, defeat has been tasted once in their most recent 6 league fixtures, and despite sitting in a seemingly lowly eleventh position, they remain a mere 6 points behind the highly-prized Champions League places. Factor in an looming two-legged Carabao Cup semi-final against the reigning champions and a strong opportunity of advancing to the European Cup last 16, and it is simpler to understand the manager's measured hope.
“Our issues aren't limited to issues,” stated the team's manager. “You can see strengths as well. I am decidedly optimistic right now. I understand others could have a opposing view, but my belief is we are making progress.”
The challenge is: can this group recreate – or perhaps exceed – the achievements of last season's Wembley triumph and fifth-place finish? Balancing a hectic fixture list complicates.
The resulting tiredness may be the reason behind the inability to maintain a stellar first-half showing against Chelsea, ultimately letting slip a two-goal lead to tie the game. Likewise, it is possibly the reason for a poor performance in a damaging loss to arch-rivals the Black Cats, where the team looked lethargic just a short time after a demanding Champions League away day.
Although coaching is clearly Howe's forte, the relentless grind of two games a week football has radically limited valuable coaching sessions. This hinders the squad's stylistic adaptation to playing with summer signing their number nine leading the line, instead of the now departed their former star. While hugely gifted, the German forward lacks the same electric breakaway pace or ferocious defensive work rate.
In fact, the side's signature pressing game has at times broken down. Injuries to vital cog the Brazilian midfielder have not helped, while high-profile arrivals the Swedish winger and Jacob Ramsey have had difficulties adapting after their combined £90m+ transfers.
If a change to a back three might theoretically benefit the team, a severe defensive injury crisis makes that difficult. First-choice full-backs will be missing for the next crucial fixtures, challenging the squad's depth.
When playing at their high-tempo best, they look almost unplayable. The problem is maintaining that fervor for the full 90 minutes. The typical plan B of sitting back into a passive counter-attacking formation has sometimes proven counterproductive.
“The Chelsea match descended into anarchic at two-all,” conceded the manager. “But the intention was going for the victory. Our mentality is to always try to secure the three points.”
What seems required is a middle ground – with better ball retention, a midfield capable of dictating the pace, and a realistic readiness to sometimes accept a point. However, a desire to challenge on all fronts is pushing finite player options to their breaking point.
This might sound unthinkable to some, but a more selective approach in the cup competitions earlier could have eased the present schedule congestion. Amid vital European and league matches on the agenda, the need to strategically prioritize is growing ever more obvious.
Eddie Howe acknowledged the magnitude of the task remaining. “When you're at this club, the pressures are big. Each game is pivotal. There is progress to be made in the league. We're in the Carabao Cup last four, we want to go through in the Europe and perform in the FA Cup.
“The direction is in the right direction, but we have plenty of work to do to become the regularly successful team we aspire to be. The ability to put sequences of victories has deserted us so far.
“The objective is to reach those levels we are aware we're able to reach. The internal belief is that the assurance to achieve it is growing. Yet now we have to demonstrate it. It's not all bad right now, but the coming period will decide a lot.”
A digital strategist with over a decade of experience in media planning and content marketing, based in London.